Select dates to see exact prices
Select dates to see exact prices
1 / 35
About Carlisle Inn
On-site dining and theater access
Access the Dutch Valley Restaurant, bakery, market, and Ohio Star Theater directly on the hotel campus.
Indoor saltwater pool and spa
Utilize the heated indoor saltwater pool and hot tub, which feature a retractable roof for seasonal flexibility.
Potential bed and shower constraints
Some guest rooms feature bed footboards and shower-tub combinations that may present challenges for mobility-impaired travelers.
On-site theater and entertainment venue
Watch regular live productions at the Ohio Star Theater located on the hotel grounds.
Private room balconies with views
Enjoy countryside views from the private balcony or patio included with every guest room.
Limited room lighting options
Select guest rooms have limited natural or artificial lighting, which some visitors find insufficient for reading or tasks.
Limited ice machine floor access
Ice machines are located exclusively on the second and third floors of the property.
The 3-star Carlisle Inn is located in Sugarcreek, offering rural valley and farm views. The hotel features an indoor pool with a retractable roof and an on-site entertainment complex including the Ohio Star Theater. Guests can dine at the Dutch Valley Restaurant and enjoy amenities such as evening cookies and popcorn service, and a library with a fireplace. Rooms include private balconies and handmade Amish-style furnishings. The hotel has a review score of 9.7 based on over 2,000 reviews, with experience, atmosphere, and the pool highlighted positively by guests.
Rooms
Classic Room
- 1 1 King Bed
- Sleeps 3
Classic Double Room
- 1 2 Queen Beds
- Sleeps 5
Executive Suite
- 1 1 King Bed
- Sleeps 3
- 1500 sq ft
Price trend
Based on lowest prices on trivago from the last 30 days
$325
$165
$0
Sun, 18/10/26
$240
Mon, 19/10/26
$249
Tue, 20/10/26
N/A
Wed, 21/10/26
$303
Thu, 22/10/26
$251
Fri, 23/10/26
N/A
Sat, 24/10/26
$232
Sun, 25/10/26
$238
Mon, 26/10/26
$325
Tue, 27/10/26
N/A
Wed, 28/10/26
N/A
Thu, 29/10/26
$258
Fri, 30/10/26
N/A
Sat, 31/10/26
N/A
Sun, 01/11/26
N/A
Mon, 02/11/26
N/A
Tue, 03/11/26
N/A
Wed, 04/11/26
N/A
Thu, 05/11/26
$250
Fri, 06/11/26
N/A
Sat, 07/11/26
N/A
Sun, 08/11/26
N/A
Mon, 09/11/26
N/A
Tue, 10/11/26
N/A
Wed, 11/11/26
N/A
Thu, 12/11/26
N/A
Fri, 13/11/26
N/A
Sat, 14/11/26
N/A
Sun, 15/11/26
N/A
Mon, 16/11/26
N/A
Tue, 17/11/26
N/A
Wed, 18/11/26
N/A
Thu, 19/11/26
N/A
Fri, 20/11/26
N/A
Sat, 21/11/26
N/A
Sun, 22/11/26
N/A
Mon, 23/11/26
N/A
Tue, 24/11/26
N/A
Wed, 25/11/26
N/A
Thu, 26/11/26
N/A
Fri, 27/11/26
N/A
Sat, 28/11/26
N/A
Sun, 29/11/26
N/A
Mon, 30/11/26
N/A
Tue, 01/12/26
N/A
Wed, 02/12/26
N/A
Thu, 03/12/26
N/A
Fri, 04/12/26
N/A
Sat, 05/12/26
N/A
Reviews
Excellent
based on 3,092 ratings from top
sites
This rating is from the trivago Rating Index (tRI), which combines guest ratings from top sites for a trustworthy result.Learn how the tRI works
sites
Review summary
Summarized by AI from 700+ reviews
A peaceful, scenic retreat in Ohio Amish Country.
This property offers families and couples a serene escape defined by its quiet, rural atmosphere. The ideal location provides walking access to the Ohio Star Theater, while the indoor swimming pool serves as a refreshing focal point for leisure. Guests consistently praise the professionalism and warmth of the staff, and those seeking extra comfort should request a room with a private balcony to fully enjoy the rolling countryside views.
Some guests mentioned: inconsistent soundproofing, limited breakfast variety, occasional snack shortages.
Rated above average for Sugarcreek
Guest reviews
Excellent90%
Very good8%
Good2%
Fair0%
Poor0%
Top amenities
- WiFi in lobby
- WiFi in rooms
- Pool
- Spa
- Parking
- A/C
- Restaurant
- Gym
All amenities
Property amenities
- Business center
- Express check-in/check-out
- Lift
- Gym
Wellness
- Hot tub
Room amenities
- Shower
- Ironing board
- Openable windows
Sports facilities
- Golf course
- Fitness
For children
- Playground
Accessibility
- Accessible travel path
Location
1357 Old Rte 39 NE, Sugarcreek, 44681, USA
Distance from Carlisle Inn
Alpine Hills Museum:3 km
Age of Steam Roundhouse Museum:6 km
Auman Museum of Radio & TV:10.9 km
:11.4 km
Schoenbrunn Village:16.8 km
Tuscarawas County Center-Arts:18 km
Ohio & Erie Canal - Lock 10:18.6 km
Fort Laurens State Memorial:19.1 km
Fort Laurens Museum:19.4 km
Uhrichsville Clay Museum:25.7 km
Byesville Scenic Railroad:60.4 km
Pittsburgh International Airport:115.9 km
Property info
1357 Old Rte 39 NE, Sugarcreek, 44681, USAFrequently Asked Questions about Carlisle Inn
Is there a pool area at Carlisle Inn?
Yes, Carlisle Inn offers 1 pool area.
Are pets allowed at Carlisle Inn?
No, Carlisle Inn doesn’t allow pets.
Is parking available at Carlisle Inn?
Yes, Carlisle Inn provides Parking for guests.
What time is check-in and check-out at Carlisle Inn?
Check-in at Carlisle Inn is available from: . Check-out time is by .
Where is Carlisle Inn located?
Carlisle Inn is located in 1357 Old Rte 39 NE, 44681, Sugarcreek, USA.
The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.
Among Top Rated Hotels in Sugarcreek
- Ramada by Wyndham Strasburg DoverSelect dates to see exact prices
- Comfort Inn & Suites DoverSelect dates to see exact prices
- Berlin ResortSee prices from 6 sitesfrom$143
- Best Western Dutch Valley InnSelect dates to see exact prices
- Lodging on the SquareSelect dates to see exact prices
- Schoenbrunn InnSelect dates to see exact prices
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Philadelphia By IhgSelect dates to see exact prices
- Hampton Inn New PhiladelphiaSelect dates to see exact prices
- TownePlace Suites by Marriott New PhiladelphiaSelect dates to see exact prices
